Engineering and Project Management
 

GFI vs CII vs FuelEU vs EU ETS: One Fleet, Four Numbers

Ask a technical manager how their fleet is doing on emissions and the honest answer is often “which number do you want?” The same vessel can simultaneously be a CII B-rated performer, a FuelEU surplus generator, an EU ETS cost centre, and — once the IMO Net-Zero Framework enters into force — a GFI deficit ship. Four regimes, four metrics, four different answers, all describing the same funnel of exhaust gas.

The problem is not just cognitive. Ships are being fitted out, chartered, and retrofitted based on whichever regime the person signing the cheque is looking at. That produces bad decisions: expensive equipment that helps one metric and does nothing for the others, or worse, helps one and hurts another.

The Four Metrics in One Table

  • CII (IMO, current) — operational carbon intensity, grams of CO₂ per tonne-mile. Annual rating A–E. Measures how efficiently a ship moves cargo, including speed reduction. Gameable by slow steaming.
  • EU ETS (EU, current) — a cost on tank-to-wake CO₂ from voyages and port calls in Europe. Not an intensity metric at all: total emissions × price. Reduced by burning less fuel in scope, period.
  • FuelEU Maritime (EU, current) — well-to-wake GHG intensity of energy used, with a target that tightens from 2025. The EU’s preview of GFI-style accounting. Rewards onboard CCS and wind assistance.
  • GFI (IMO, from 2028 at the earliest) — well-to-wake GHG intensity of energy used, fleet-global scope, with a two-tier deficit/pricing mechanism and rewards for clean fuels.

Two of the four reward low-carbon fuel. One rewards low total fuel. One rewards operational efficiency. A compliance strategy that only understands one of them is not a strategy.

Where the Metrics Pull in Different Directions

Slow steaming. Excellent for CII and ETS. Effectively neutral for FuelEU and GFI — intensity metrics don’t care how fast you go, only how clean the energy is.

LNG dual-fuel. Improves tank-to-wake CO₂ (helps ETS, helps CII) and usually improves FuelEU/GFI — unless methane slip eats the advantage. Well-to-wake accounting is merciless about slip, which is why the same LNG decision can look brilliant in an ETS model and marginal in a GFI model.

Biofuel blends. Certifiable, drop-in, and genuinely valuable under FuelEU and GFI — but currently of zero benefit to CII, which counts tank-to-wake CO₂ only, and modest benefit to ETS, which in its current form treats biogenic CO₂ under its own accounting rules.

Onboard carbon capture. Barely visible to CII, expensive for ETS energy balance, and one of the strongest levers under FuelEU and the coming GFI — where capture accounting credits are being built into the rules.

Wind-assisted propulsion. A direct intensity-metric win (FuelEU multiplier, GFI rewards) and a real fuel saving, but the CII benefit is indirect.

The Unified Approach

One fleet, four numbers — but one physical reality: fuel mass, fuel quality, and energy delivered to the propeller. The fleets that win under all four regimes are the ones that manage the underlying engineering once and let the metrics follow:

  1. One data chain feeding all four reports, instead of four spreadsheets with four versions of the same voyage
  2. One retrofit ranking that scores each measure against all four metrics before capital is committed
  3. One fuel strategy that models each fuel pathway against well-to-wake accounting — the strictest of the four — knowing that a fuel that passes GFI passes everything

How We Help

Ingeniat builds exactly this: unified emissions baselines, retrofit feasibility engineering scored across regimes, and monitoring chains that produce every report from one auditable dataset. We work across CII, EEXI, EU ETS, and FuelEU for fleets today, and we are already modelling the GFI layer for the Net-Zero era. Four numbers, one engineering programme.

Related Reading

→ See our FuelEU Maritime compliance services


Stop optimizing for one metric and getting surprised by the other three. Contact us to build a single emissions strategy that holds up across every regime your fleet reports to.